{ "example": "etale-ios", "skill": "cast", "stack": "SwiftUI, iOS 26.0 deployment target, Swift 5 language mode with MainActor default isolation, no dependency", "prompt": "/genjutsu:cast Étale's iOS day list should open into the tide detail as one surface, not a push\n\nÉtale is a fictional slack-water app, made up for this example. Its numbers are real NOAA predictions for 2 October 2026.\n\nNobody is available to answer questions during this session. Up-front answers to the gates:\n- Preview mode: A. Write each preview as a standalone HTML file under preview/ in the project.\n- Scope: the Today list and the tide detail it opens. You may edit and add Swift files under Etale/ and write previews under preview/; create nothing outside the project. Etale/ is a folder the Xcode project keeps in sync with the disk: a Swift file added there is compiled, so do not edit Etale.xcodeproj.\n- The app targets iOS 26 and is built with Xcode 27. Xcode cannot run in this session: do not try to build. There is no network: install nothing.\n\nFinish with the final report the pipeline asks for.", "model": "claude-opus-5-5", "date": "2026-11-13", "runs_recorded": 6, "selection": "six runs of one prompt, told in order; every run made is here, none was dropped and none was run again. Run 1 on genjutsu 4.1.3, run 2 on the module fixes, run 3 on the 4.2.0 release branch (a smoke run), runs 4 to 6 on the release branch plus the step 'thesis against loaded modules'", "what_the_pair_does_not_prove": "run 2 named the zoom transition before reading any module, so the choice came from the model, not from the fixed swiftui-motion; the same model and prompt did not make that choice in run 1, nor in run 3 on the same fixed modules", "between_runs": { "genjutsu_commits": [ "fd4e1da", "3e0d6d3" ], "branch": "fix/native-shared-element", "released": "not when run 2 was made; part of the 4.2.0 release branch that runs 3 to 6 ran on", "fixes": [ { "gap": "no module named the system transition for a row that opens its detail", "files": [ "skills/_jutsu/swiftui-motion/SKILL.md:28", "skills/_jutsu/swiftui-motion/SKILL.md:112", "skills/_jutsu/swiftui-motion/SKILL.md:144" ] }, { "gap": "the DragGesture examples had no coordinate space for a drag that moves its own view", "files": [ "skills/_jutsu/swiftui-motion/SKILL.md:310", "skills/_jutsu/swiftui-motion/references/gestures-swiftui.md:55", "skills/_jutsu/mobile-principles/references/gestures-deep.md" ] }, { "gap": "the edge-swipe back was 'Never override', a ban a run could wave away", "files": [ "skills/_jutsu/mobile-principles/SKILL.md:194" ] }, { "gap": "the audit did not confront the code with the rules of the loaded modules", "files": [ "skills/cast/SKILL.md:674", "skills/paint/SKILL.md:957", "skills/bunshin/SKILL.md:918" ] }, { "gap": "dated claims", "files": [ "skills/_jutsu/VERSIONS.md (two rows dated 2026-11-13)" ] } ] }, "runs": [ { "run": 1, "runs_dir": "runs/20261113T184049Z", "media_dir": "media", "genjutsu": { "version": "4.1.3", "commit": "5e00595", "note": "the v4.1.3 tag (ac9ca74) plus two README-only commits" }, "harness": { "tool": "claude plugin eval", "claude_code": "2.1.323", "headless": true, "note": "nobody answered the gates; the skill's 'When nobody is answering' rule applied. bin/run.sh run from a copy with the cost ceiling at 15 USD and the plugin copied to /private/tmp/genjutsu-eval-ex-ios" }, "started_at": "2026-11-13T18:40:50.649Z", "cost_usd": 3.42, "cost_usd_exact": 3.423506, "turns": 22, "duration_seconds": 898, "duration_note": "898 s is the run's own duration in its trace (not committed); the harness prints 900 s for the whole case", "subagents": 0, "tokens": { "input": 40, "output": 94563, "cache_read": 1792950, "cache_creation": 146687 }, "modules_loaded": [ "motion-principles", "mobile-principles", "swiftui-motion" ], "modules_not_loaded": [], "interaction_thesis": "Tapping a slack row grows that row's own card into the full tide detail.\n- The card's clip opens from the row's frame to the whole screen.\n- The row's three lines (time, turn, next current) move to their places in the detail header, and the time scales up to the 56 pt hero.\n- All of it runs on one `spring(duration: 0.45, bounce: 0)`, which never overshoots: slack water is the moment the current stands still.\n- The rest of the detail fades in after the card has mostly grown (0.2 s ease-out, 0.15 s delay) and fades out first when closing (0.12 s ease-in).\n- Dragging the header down collapses the card back into its row.", "allowed_patterns": "none", "unvalidated": true, "assumptions": "the feel is still and exact, no bounce; the edge-swipe back is gone because the detail is an overlay, replaced by a header drag, a close button and the VoiceOver escape; the List became a ScrollView of cards; the next-current line moved into the detail's header", "variant_picked": "B, \"the lines move\", from three (A only the card grows, C also draws the tide curve)", "audit": { "summary": "10 checks, 2 problems, 5 for you to run", "problems": [ "rows have no disabled look while the detail is open", "layout spacing is literal numbers; the project has no spacing tokens" ], "listed_not_counted": "secondaryLabel on white is 3.4:1, under 4.5:1 for 15 pt text; system colour, already in the starting app", "tells": "not applicable on SwiftUI; never requested", "unverified": [ "the build (Xcode could not run in the session)", "Instruments > Animation Hitches", "Reduce Motion on, Dynamic Type at 200%", "VoiceOver focus on open and close", "Full Keyboard Access and Esc" ], "compile_risks_named_by_the_run": [ "nonisolated struct", "the onGeometryChange closure signatures", "whether visualEffect interpolates under the spring" ], "compile_risks_that_materialized": 0 }, "files_changed": { "Etale/SlackSurface.swift": "new, 126 lines (motion constants, row frame store, RevealShape clip, travels visualEffect, content fade)", "Etale/TodayView.swift": "rewritten (List to ScrollView of cards, rows as buttons that report their frames, overlay above the NavigationStack, open/expand/close)", "Etale/TideDetailView.swift": "rewritten (full-screen layer clipped by RevealShape, header with close button, fading content, header drag, Reduce Motion path; TideCurve unchanged)", "stat": "3 files, 487 insertions, 78 deletions against the starting app" }, "previews": [ "preview/thesis.html", "preview/variants.html" ], "selection": "the only run made on 4.1.3", "build": { "result": "success", "first_try": true, "errors": [], "compiler_warnings": 0, "command": "xcodebuild -project Etale.xcodeproj -scheme Etale -configuration Debug -destination 'platform=iOS Simulator,id=' -derivedDataPath /private/tmp/etale-ios-run-dd CODE_SIGNING_ALLOWED=NO build", "toolchain": "Xcode 27.2 (27B52), iOS 27.2 simulator SDK, iPhone 17 simulator on iOS 26.5", "note": "the run could not build (no Xcode in its session) and wrote 487 lines of Swift without a compiler; it built here unchanged on the first try" }, "human_edits": 0, "human_edits_needed": 1, "human_edits_needed_detail": "Etale/TideDetailView.swift:177, DragGesture(minimumDistance: 10) to DragGesture(minimumDistance: 10, coordinateSpace: .global), for the drag defect; tried in a copy outside the repository (builds, the drag no longer alternates); not applied here", "edits_diff": null, "grader_score": { "score": 1.0, "note": "five of five: cast-fired, cast-loaded, list-opens-detail, swiftui-motion-loaded, tells-never-requested" }, "thesis_against_capture": { "card_grows_from_row_to_screen": true, "lines_travel_and_time_scales": "yes, with overlaps", "no_overshoot": true, "content_fades_in_after_and_leaves_first": true, "drag_collapses": "it collapses on release, but the drag flickers every frame", "visible_change_seconds": { "open": 0.8, "close": 0.9, "system_push_before": 0.43, "system_back_before": 0.63 } }, "defects": [ { "what": "the drag that closes the detail flickers: the surface alternates between two positions on successive frames", "where": "Etale/TideDetailView.swift:177 (a local-space DragGesture on a header that the same drag offsets and scales, lines 64-65)", "evidence": "media/defect-drag.webp, media/defect-drag-a.png, media/defect-drag-b.png", "fix": "coordinateSpace: .global, one line, verified in a copy, not applied" }, { "what": "the time and the turn line are drawn over each other at the start of the opening and the end of the closing", "evidence": "media/open-early.png, media/close-mid.png" }, { "what": "the travelling lines cross the label and divider that are fading in", "evidence": "media/open-mid.png" }, { "what": "the edge-swipe back, the navigation bar, its title and back button are gone: the detail is an overlay, not a navigation destination; the system zoom transition (matchedTransitionSource + navigationTransition(.zoom), iOS 18) was not considered", "evidence": "media/detail.png against before/detail.png" }, { "what": "both screens were restyled to make the effect possible: List to hand-drawn cards without chevrons, detail without grouped sections or its Current row, lower half empty", "evidence": "media/today.png, media/detail.png against before/" }, { "what": "at the accessibility-large text size the travelling text re-breaks on the first frame and crosses the divider", "evidence": "media/large-type-mid.png" }, { "what": "the row's time changes by about a pixel when the collapsed surface is swapped for the row, 1.1 to 1.2 s after Close", "evidence": "frames of the testOpenAndClose take" } ], "suspected": [ "the list cannot be tapped for about a second after Close (TodayView.swift:94 with the completion at line 151); the driver waits for idle, so the takes cannot show it", "Close tapped mid-opening, and a second row tapped while the first collapses: guarded in the code, not filmed", "the release of the drag compares the same local-space translation with 120 pt (TideDetailView.swift:184), so a release between about 120 and 240 pt may close or spring back depending on the last frame; only the 300 pt drag was filmed", "under Reduce Motion, a row reopened within 0.2 s of Close has isExpanded reset to false by the pending completion (TodayView.swift:141-147), and the header drag then does nothing; the close button still works", "the row's frames are read once at the tap (TodayView.swift:117): a text size change while the detail is open collapses the card onto the row's old place", "the spring redraws a clip path every frame over a full-screen layer holding a ScrollView and the stroked curve; hitches not measured" ], "unverified": [ "no real device: frame pacing, hitches and 120 Hz (Instruments > Animation Hitches not run)", "VoiceOver: focus on open and close, modal trait, escape gesture", "Full Keyboard Access and the Esc shortcut", "the flick that closes (predicted end past 240 pt) and a drag released before 120 pt", "opening a row after the list has scrolled", "Dynamic Type beyond accessibility-large, right-to-left, Increase Contrast", "haptics: none in the code, none claimed", "dark appearance contrast (filmed once, not computed)" ], "genjutsu_gaps": [ "skills/_jutsu/swiftui-motion/SKILL.md:28 answers 'Shared element transitions' with matchedGeometryEffect only; no module names navigationTransition(.zoom) and matchedTransitionSource", "skills/_jutsu/swiftui-motion/SKILL.md:267 teaches DragGesture().onChanged { offset = value.translation } without the coordinate space a gesture needs when it is attached to the view it moves; references/gestures-swiftui.md:53 presents coordinateSpace as 'useful for cross-view drags'", "skills/_jutsu/mobile-principles/SKILL.md:194 says of the edge-swipe back 'Never override'; the run loaded it, set it aside in one sentence, and its audit did not count it" ], "capture": { "device": "iPhone 17 simulator, iOS 26.5, 1206x2622 px (402x874 pt at 3x)", "recorder": "xcrun simctl io recordVideo --codec=h264", "taps": "XCUITest, takes/driver: a UI test bundle in its own Xcode project with no target application, driving the installed app by bundle identifier; not part of the app build", "frames": "takes/frames.swift (AVFoundation; no ffmpeg on the machine)", "encode": "takes/encode-clip.py (magick, as bin/record.mjs)", "commands": "takes/make-media.sh", "time": "real", "recordings_committed": false, "build": "build-20261113T184049Z-1 (a copy of runs/20261113T184049Z/workspace-1)" }, "media": [ { "file": "media/clip.webp", "output": "402x874", "kb": 658, "what": "the run's build: tap the 10:31 row at about 0.6 s, its card grows to the screen, the three lines travel, the curve and the switch fade in; Close at about 3.2 s, the card shrinks back into its row; the same on the 16:17 row at about 5.7 s and 8.4 s. The time-over-turn overlap shows at each start and end", "duration_s": 10, "fps": 24, "quality": 66, "annotation": "no pointer is drawn: XCUITest performs the taps" }, { "file": "media/today.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 178, "what": "the Today screen at rest, as the run rewrote it" }, { "file": "media/open-early.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 135, "what": "about 70 ms after the tap: the card has left the row; \"10:31\" overlaps \"Ebb turns to flood\"" }, { "file": "media/open-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 118, "what": "about 170 ms after the tap: the card near full size, the lines over the half-faded label and divider" }, { "file": "media/detail.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 92, "what": "the detail, settled" }, { "file": "media/close-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 146, "what": "about 320 ms after Close: the card almost back on its row, content gone, the time over the turn line" }, { "file": "media/alert.webp", "output": "402x874", "kb": 208, "what": "the alert switch turned on in the detail, then Close: the bell is on the 10:31 row when the card lands", "duration_s": 5, "fps": 24, "quality": 66 }, { "file": "media/alert-row.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 179, "what": "the row with its bell" }, { "file": "media/defect-drag.webp", "output": "320x696", "kb": 542, "what": "the defect: the header dragged down 300 pt in one second, the surface alternates between two positions on successive frames", "duration_s": 1.5, "fps": 60, "quality": 62 }, { "file": "media/defect-drag-a.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 99, "what": "one frame of that drag: the surface about 35 pt down" }, { "file": "media/defect-drag-b.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 104, "what": "the next frame, 17 ms later: the surface about 74 pt down" }, { "file": "media/reduced.webp", "output": "402x874", "kb": 189, "what": "Reduce Motion on: the detail cross-fades over the list in about 0.2 s, nothing grows or travels; the same back", "duration_s": 4.2, "fps": 24, "quality": 66 }, { "file": "media/reduced-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 204, "what": "the middle of that cross-fade" }, { "file": "media/dark-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 120, "what": "dark appearance, mid-opening" }, { "file": "media/dark-detail.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 106, "what": "dark appearance, settled" }, { "file": "media/large-type-today.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 152, "what": "text size accessibility-large: the list" }, { "file": "media/large-type-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 160, "what": "text size accessibility-large, mid-opening: the lines re-break and cross the divider" }, { "file": "media/large-type-detail.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 147, "what": "text size accessibility-large: the settled detail" }, { "file": "media/preview.png", "output": "1280x900", "kb": 186, "what": "preview/thesis.html, first screen" }, { "file": "media/preview-variants.png", "output": "1280x900", "kb": 128, "what": "preview/variants.html, first screen" }, { "file": "before/push.webp", "output": "402x874", "kb": 704, "what": "the starting app, same driver test: the system push to the detail and back, twice", "duration_s": 12.4, "fps": 24, "quality": 66 }, { "file": "before/today.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 143, "what": "the starting app: the list" }, { "file": "before/push-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 139, "what": "the starting app: mid-push" }, { "file": "before/detail.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 120, "what": "the starting app: the detail" } ], "second_check": "a separate pass replayed the trace's Write calls (the three Swift files are byte for byte the run's), rebuilt a fresh copy of workspace-1 (BUILD SUCCEEDED, no compiler error or warning) and read frames of the committed clips; the timings and the one-pixel pop were not measured again" }, { "run": 2, "runs_dir": "runs/20261113T201315Z", "media_dir": "media/run-2", "genjutsu": { "version": "4.1.4", "commit": "3e0d6d3", "commit_full": "3e0d6d3e31f1ad38e5e59817fa80cb9adb60bcb1", "branch": "fix/native-shared-element", "released": false, "note": "v4.1.4 (d5c614a) plus the two module-fix commits that shipped in 4.2.0, fd4e1da and 3e0d6d3; the harness prints 4.1.4" }, "harness": { "tool": "claude plugin eval", "claude_code": "2.1.323", "headless": true, "note": "the same copy of bin/run.sh as run 1 (cost ceiling 15 USD, plugin copied to /private/tmp/genjutsu-eval-ex-ios); nobody answered the gates" }, "started_at": "2026-11-13T20:13:16.517Z", "cost_usd": 1.53, "cost_usd_exact": 1.529563, "turns": 22, "duration_seconds": 330, "duration_note": "330 s is the run's own duration in its trace (not committed); the harness prints 331 s for the whole case", "subagents": 0, "tokens": { "input": 28, "output": 32837, "cache_read": 832233, "cache_creation": 88283 }, "modules_loaded": [ "motion-principles", "mobile-principles", "swiftui-motion" ], "modules_not_loaded": [], "interaction_thesis": "Opening a slack from the Today list uses iOS 26's zoom navigation transition (`.matchedTransitionSource` on the row, `.navigationTransition(.zoom)` on the detail). The row grows into the tide detail as one surface and shrinks back into its own place on dismiss, including by dragging. Once the detail lands, the curve's slack marker settles in: the dashed rule draws top to bottom and the dot grows from 0.5 to 1. It runs on a critically damped `.spring(duration: 0.45, bounce: 0)` after a 0.35 s delay, because at slack the water stops and nothing in this app overshoots. With Reduce Motion on, the detail uses the system's automatic transition and the marker is already in place.", "allowed_patterns": "the dashed marker rule and dot on the tide curve (already in the app, now drawn once on arrival)", "unvalidated": true, "assumptions": "users are people who swim or paddle at Aquatic Park; the detail stays a navigation destination (back button, edge swipe and title bar keep working, dismissing is interactive); variant B", "variant_picked": "B, the zoom starts from a surface coloured like the list cell with 12 pt corners, from three (A starts from the bare row, C also opens from the \"Next slack water\" header)", "thesis_written_before_modules_loaded": true, "thesis_order_note": "the run's thesis page names the zoom transition before its first load_skill call; the first occurrence of 'zoom' in the trace is that page, and neither the app's sources nor the cast skill names the API. The choice came from the model; the fixed modules, read after, agree with it", "audit": { "summary": "11 checked, 2 problems, 3 handed over", "loaded_modules_against_code": { "printed": true, "lines": [ { "module": "motion-principles", "rule": "never exceed 500 ms on a UI interaction", "where": "TideTransition.swift:12,15,17", "outcome": "problem: the unvalidated thesis asks for it, so it licenses nothing", "true": "yes: the rule is motion-principles/SKILL.md:211 and 0.35 s + 0.45 s is 0.8 s on paper; on film the marker is visibly finished about 0.55 s after the first frame of the zoom" }, { "module": "none named", "rule": "the 0.35 s delay is a guess at the duration of the system zoom", "outcome": "problem, untested", "true": "yes: the zoom stops moving about 0.45 s after its first frame, the rule starts to draw at 0.33 s, the dot shows at 0.45 s" }, { "note": "if Reduce Motion changes while a detail is open, the detail rebuilds and its marker draws again", "true": "plausible from the code, not tried" }, { "module": "mobile-principles", "outcome": "edge swipe kept, no departure", "true": "yes, filmed" }, { "module": "swiftui-motion", "outcome": "the zoom sits on the detail's root view, no departure", "true": "yes: TodayView.swift:61 through TideTransition.swift:52, and the zoom runs" } ], "not_listed": "under Reduce Motion the fallback is the system push, a full-screen slide; swiftui-motion/SKILL.md:403 says large translations must be neutralized under reduced motion. It is the system's own transition and the starting app's behaviour, and the audit passed its Reduce Motion check; a strict reading would have listed it" }, "problems": [ "the marker settles after about 0.8 s on paper, over the 500 ms of motion-principles; asked for by the unvalidated thesis", "the 0.35 s delay is a guess at the duration of the system zoom (untested)" ], "tells": "not applicable on SwiftUI; never requested", "unverified": [ "the build (Xcode could not run in the session)", "Instruments > Animation Hitches, opening and dismissing each slack, including by dragging", "Reduce Motion on, Dynamic Type at 200%" ] }, "files_changed": { "Etale/TideTransition.swift": "new, 55 lines (motion constants, the row as zoom source with a cell-coloured background, the zoom on the destination unless Reduce Motion is on)", "Etale/TodayView.swift": "3 lines added (a namespace, the source on each row, the zoom on the destination); List, NavigationStack, NavigationLink and navigationDestination as they were", "Etale/TideDetailView.swift": "20 lines added inside TideCurve (the marker rule trims in, the dot scales from 0.5 and fades in, once, on appear; at rest under Reduce Motion)", "stat": "3 files, 78 insertions, 0 deletions against the starting app" }, "screens_at_rest_vs_starting_app": "unchanged: media/run-2/today.png against before/today.png and media/run-2/detail.png against before/detail.png differ only by video-compression noise; of 790533 pixels, 66 and 0 differ by more than 2% of the colour range (5 of 255), scattered along text edges, largest difference 25 and 5 of 255; 26705 and 1810 differ at all (frames of an H.264 recording, not screenshots)", "previews": [ "preview/thesis.html", "preview/variants.html" ], "selection": "the only run made on 3e0d6d3; not picked among several. Four later runs of the same prompt are runs 3 to 6", "build": { "result": "success", "first_try": true, "verbatim": "** BUILD SUCCEEDED **", "errors": [], "compiler_warnings": 0, "other_warnings": [ "warning: Metadata extraction skipped, no AppIntents.framework dependency found (the starting app prints it too)" ], "command": "xcodebuild -project Etale.xcodeproj -scheme Etale -configuration Debug -destination 'platform=iOS Simulator,id=' -derivedDataPath /private/tmp/etale-ios-run2-dd CODE_SIGNING_ALLOWED=NO build", "toolchain": "Xcode 27.2 (27B52), iOS 27.2 simulator SDK, iPhone 17 simulator on iOS 26.5", "note": "the run could not build and wrote its Swift without a compiler; it built here unchanged on the first try, with new derived data" }, "human_edits": 0, "human_edits_needed": 0, "human_edits_worth_making": "remove or rework the source background (TideTransition.swift:29-33), which shows as a white box inside the highlighted cell after each return; not tried", "edits_diff": null, "grader_score": { "score": 1.0, "note": "five of five, the same graders as run 1" }, "answers": { "used_system_zoom_transition": true, "kept_navigation_stack_bar_back_button": true, "kept_edge_swipe_back": "yes, filmed, interactive", "any_drag_flickers": "no: 0 reversals over 78 frames at 60 fps on the downward drag, 0 before release on the edge swipe", "audit_module_check_printed": "yes: 2 problems, 1 note, 2 no-departure lines", "audit_module_check_true": "yes, every line; it did not list the Reduce Motion slide", "redesigned_screens_nobody_asked_about": false }, "thesis_against_capture": { "row_grows_into_detail_and_back": true, "dismiss_by_dragging": "yes: edge swipe and drag down, both interactive", "marker_settles_after_landing": "about at the landing: rule from 0.33 s, dot at 0.45 s, zoom still at 0.45 s", "no_overshoot": true, "reduce_motion": "the system push instead of the zoom, marker in place from the first frame", "visible_change_seconds": { "open": 0.45, "open_with_marker": 0.57, "close": 0.55, "system_push_before": 0.43, "system_back_before": 0.63 } }, "defects": [ { "what": "a white rounded rectangle, the zoom source's own background, shows inside the still-highlighted grey cell for about 0.4 s after the detail lands back", "where": "Etale/TideTransition.swift:29-33", "evidence": "media/run-2/defect-source-box.png, the end of each return in media/run-2/clip.webp", "measured": "at 60 fps: when the zoom has landed, about 0.5 s after Back, the cell outside the box is at 251 of 255 against the box's 255, and snaps to white 0.92 s after Back; on screen about 0.4 s at a faint contrast" }, { "what": "the marker's 0.35 s delay is a constant guessed against a duration the system owns; right on this simulator, not guaranteed elsewhere", "where": "Etale/TideTransition.swift:15", "evidence": "media/run-2/marker-mid.png" }, { "what": "the marker may draw a second time if Reduce Motion changes while the detail is open", "where": "Etale/TideTransition.swift:49, Etale/TideDetailView.swift:116", "evidence": "read in the code, not tried" }, { "what": "under Reduce Motion the transition is the system push, a full-screen slide, not a cross-fade", "evidence": "media/run-2/reduced.webp" } ], "run_1_defects_gone": [ "flickering drag", "text overlapping in flight", "lost edge swipe, bar, title and back button", "restyled screens", "hand-off jump at large type", "list untappable for a second after closing" ], "less_than_run_1": "no bespoke choreography: the system cross-fades the row into the detail and owns the curve; the only motion that is the app's own is the marker", "unverified": [ "no real device and no iOS 18 runtime: frame pacing, hitches, 120 Hz (Instruments > Animation Hitches not run)", "VoiceOver and Full Keyboard Access (nothing custom was added)", "an edge swipe or drag released early, a tap during the zoom", "opening a row after the list has scrolled; the 16:17 row at accessibility-large (below the fold, the driver cannot reach it)", "Dynamic Type beyond accessibility-large, right-to-left, Increase Contrast, iPad", "what the system zoom does under Reduce Motion (the run switches it off)", "dark appearance contrast (filmed once, not computed)" ], "capture": { "device": "iPhone 17 simulator, iOS 26.5, 1206x2622 px (402x874 pt at 3x)", "same_as_run_1": "recorder, status bar, frames, encode", "commands": "takes/make-media-run-2.sh", "tracking": "takes/track.py", "driver_changes": [ "testEdgeSwipeBack added: a 300 pt drag from the leading edge (run 1's overlay had no such gesture)", "testAlert taps the switch at its trailing end instead of its centre: in a List row the switch element is as wide as the row and a centre tap lands on the label (the first take of run 2 showed no switch and no bell)" ], "recordings_committed": false, "build": "build-20261113T201315Z-1 (a copy of runs/20261113T201315Z/workspace-1)" }, "media": [ { "file": "media/run-2/clip.webp", "output": "402x874", "kb": 693, "what": "run 2's build: tap the 10:31 row at about 0.6 s, the detail zooms out of the row, the marker settles; Back at about 4.1 s, the detail shrinks into its row; the same on the 16:17 row at about 7.4 s and 10.9 s. The white box shows on the row at the end of each return", "duration_s": 12.3, "fps": 24, "quality": 62 }, { "file": "media/run-2/today.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 141, "what": "the Today screen at rest: the starting app's, unchanged" }, { "file": "media/run-2/open-early.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 145, "what": "about 35 ms after the first frame of the zoom" }, { "file": "media/run-2/open-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 156, "what": "about 100 ms: the detail near full size, the list dimmed behind" }, { "file": "media/run-2/marker-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 134, "what": "about 370 ms: the zoom all but landed, the dashed rule drawn, the dot not yet" }, { "file": "media/run-2/detail.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 119, "what": "the detail, settled: navigation bar, title, back button, grouped sections" }, { "file": "media/run-2/close-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 142, "what": "about 170 ms after Back: the detail shrinking onto its row" }, { "file": "media/run-2/defect-source-box.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 143, "what": "about 0.6 s after Back: the white source rectangle inside the still-grey 10:31 cell" }, { "file": "media/run-2/edge-swipe.webp", "output": "402x874", "kb": 424, "what": "the edge-swipe back: a 300 pt drag from the leading edge over one second, then release", "duration_s": 2.4, "fps": 24, "quality": 62 }, { "file": "media/run-2/edge-swipe-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 221, "what": "mid-swipe: the detail under the finger, smaller, a gap in the list where the row is" }, { "file": "media/run-2/drag-down.webp", "output": "402x874", "kb": 384, "what": "the same downward drag as run 1's media/defect-drag.webp: the detail follows and shrinks, no alternation", "duration_s": 2.4, "fps": 24, "quality": 62 }, { "file": "media/run-2/drag-down-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 164, "what": "mid-drag" }, { "file": "media/run-2/alert.webp", "output": "402x874", "kb": 212, "what": "the alert switch turned on, then Back: the bell is on the 10:31 row", "duration_s": 5, "fps": 24, "quality": 66 }, { "file": "media/run-2/alert-row.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 135, "what": "the row with its bell" }, { "file": "media/run-2/reduced.webp", "output": "402x874", "kb": 375, "what": "Reduce Motion on: the system push and pop, no zoom, the marker in place from the first frame", "duration_s": 4.5, "fps": 24, "quality": 66 }, { "file": "media/run-2/reduced-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 197, "what": "the middle of that push" }, { "file": "media/run-2/dark-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 115, "what": "dark appearance, mid-zoom" }, { "file": "media/run-2/dark-detail.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 125, "what": "dark appearance, settled" }, { "file": "media/run-2/large-type-today.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 145, "what": "text size accessibility-large: the list" }, { "file": "media/run-2/large-type-mid.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 142, "what": "text size accessibility-large, mid-zoom" }, { "file": "media/run-2/large-type-detail.png", "output": "603x1311", "kb": 139, "what": "text size accessibility-large: the settled detail" }, { "file": "media/run-2/preview.png", "output": "1280x900", "kb": 207, "what": "preview/thesis.html, first screen" }, { "file": "media/run-2/preview-variants.png", "output": "1280x900", "kb": 188, "what": "preview/variants.html, first screen" } ], "thesis_note": "the thesis misdates the API: the zoom navigation transition shipped in iOS 18, not iOS 26; the code is right at this deployment target either way", "suspected_from_code": [ "the marker's one-time flag is @State of TideCurve (TideDetailView.swift:70) in a row of the detail's List, started in that row's onAppear (line 116): where the detail scrolls, a curve below the fold would start its delay only when it scrolls in, and could draw again if the list drops the row's state off screen; the detail does not scroll on the iPhone 17 at the default size, so no take shows it" ], "second_check": "a separate pass replayed the trace's three Write and six Edit calls on the starting app (the three Swift files and the two previews are byte for byte the run's), rebuilt a fresh copy of workspace-1 with new derived data (BUILD SUCCEEDED, no compiler error or warning), dumped the two drag recordings again at 60 fps and tracked the curve with its own script (downward drag 1171 to 1874 px with no reversal, edge swipe 94 to 873 px with one turn at the release; in the committed clips 0 reversals in media/run-2/drag-down.webp against 56 in media/defect-drag.webp), searched the trace (nothing before the thesis page names the zoom API, the edge swipe or a shared element; the plugin copy is identical to 3e0d6d3), and checked cost, turns, duration, tokens, subagents, the audit quotes and the file:line citations; it corrected the pixel counts of the screens at rest and added the white box measurement, the misdated API and the List row item; no new recording was filmed" }, { "run": 3, "runs_dir": "runs/20261113T213153Z", "media_dir": "media/run-3", "genjutsu": { "version": "4.2.0", "commit": "5105f53", "commit_full": "5105f535a27135903926fb6a8c96c1c5b15f9185", "branch": "release/v4.2.0", "module_fixes": true, "step_thesis_against_modules": false, "note": "a smoke run of the release branch" }, "harness": { "tool": "claude plugin eval", "claude_code": "2.1.325", "headless": true, "note": "a copy of bin/run.sh with its paths changed; one run" }, "started_at": "2026-11-13T21:31:54.176Z", "cost_usd": 2.46, "cost_usd_exact": 2.4578198, "turns": 25, "duration_seconds": 605, "duration_note": "605 s in the run's trace (not committed); the harness prints 606 s", "subagents": 0, "tokens": { "input": 44, "output": 58109, "cache_read": 1801719, "cache_creation": 116890 }, "modules_loaded": [ "motion-principles", "mobile-principles", "swiftui-motion" ], "modules_not_loaded": [], "interaction_thesis": "Tapping a slack row grows that row, in place, into the tide detail as one surface on a critically damped spring (`.spring(duration: 0.45, bounce: 0)`, since slack water does not overshoot). The slack time is the still point: it moves from the row to the head of the detail and never fades. The rest of the detail fades in and rises 12 pt over the second half of the travel. Dragging the head down, or swiping in from the leading edge, shrinks the surface back into its row under the finger. With Reduce Motion on, the finished detail crossfades in over 200 ms instead. Leaving the push loses the edge-swipe back, the bar and its back button, the VoiceOver escape gesture and the navigation path. A leading-edge swipe, a close button and `.accessibilityAction(.escape)` replace the first three; nothing replaces the path, which the app does not restore or deep-link today.", "allowed_patterns": "none", "unvalidated": true, "thesis_written_before_modules_loaded": true, "thesis_named_zoom_before_modules_loaded": false, "thesis_order_note": "the preview with the hand-built surface was written before the three loads; after them the run kept the surface and added to the thesis what leaving the push costs. Its reasoning summary: \"Since the brief rules out a push, I'm keeping the custom surface, naming each replacement in the thesis, and adding a leading-edge swipe.\"", "used_system_zoom_transition": false, "kept_navigation_stack_bar_back_button": false, "swift_changed": { "files": 3, "insertions": 434, "deletions": 59 }, "files_changed": { "Etale/SlackSurface.swift": "new, 280 lines", "Etale/TodayView.swift": "rewritten; NavigationLink and navigationDestination removed", "Etale/TideDetailView.swift": "only the detail's body; header moved into the surface, navigation title gone" }, "previews": [ "preview/slack-surface.html" ], "audit": { "summary": "10 checked, 5 problems found, 3 handed over", "loaded_modules_against_code": { "printed": true, "problems": [ "hand-built surface instead of the system zoom transition (mobile-principles, swipe-back; swiftui-motion, zoom transition), TodayView.swift:21-45", "exit is not quieter than entry (motion-principles), TodayView.swift:125", "leading-edge strip intercepts touches, SlackSurface.swift:208-219" ], "all_true": true, "acted_on": false } }, "build": { "result": "success", "first_try": true, "verbatim": "** BUILD SUCCEEDED **", "errors": [], "compiler_warnings": 0, "other_warnings": [ "warning: Metadata extraction skipped, no AppIntents.framework dependency found" ], "from": "a fresh copy of runs/20261113T213153Z/workspace-1, new derived data, iPhone 17 simulator on iOS 26.5" }, "human_edits": 0, "grader_score": { "score": 1.0, "note": "five of five, the same graders as run 1; they do not judge the motion" }, "defects": [ { "what": "the time lands on the wrong row: after a return, 10:31 sits in the 05:57 row and the 10:31 row has no time", "media": "media/run-3/defect-wrong-row.png" }, { "what": "the large time sits under the Dynamic Island, over its own 'Slack water' label", "media": "media/run-3/detail.png" }, { "what": "the Today list shows under the settled detail", "media": "media/run-3/detail.png" }, { "what": "both screens restyled: no bar, title or back button, tinted row text, no chevrons", "media": "media/run-3/today.png" }, { "what": "after the drag a white card with only the time stays over the first two rows in the last frames of the take", "media": "media/run-3/drag-down.webp" } ], "unverified": [ "whether the drag flickers frame by frame", "timings", "Reduce Motion, dark appearance, large type", "no real device", "no second check of the measurements" ], "hygiene_note": "the run's preview/slack-surface.html had a U+2014 dash in its ; it is ' - ' here. Nothing else in the workspace was touched", "media": [ { "file": "media/run-3/clip.webp", "kb": 470 }, { "file": "media/run-3/edge-swipe.webp", "kb": 118 }, { "file": "media/run-3/drag-down.webp", "kb": 258 }, { "file": "media/run-3/today.png" }, { "file": "media/run-3/detail.png" }, { "file": "media/run-3/defect-wrong-row.png" } ] }, { "run": 4, "runs_dir": "runs/20261113T220815Z", "media_dir": "media/run-4", "genjutsu": { "version": "4.2.0", "commit": "844f375", "commit_full": "844f37558c90215e4f7b93fdf96838f39c1e9967", "branch": "release/v4.2.0", "module_fixes": true, "step_thesis_against_modules": true }, "harness": { "tool": "claude plugin eval", "claude_code": "2.1.325", "headless": true, "note": "the same copy of bin/run.sh as run 3 with its paths changed, cost ceiling 6 USD; one run, started side by side with the two others" }, "started_at": "2026-11-13T22:08:15.746Z", "cost_usd": 1.36, "cost_usd_exact": 1.3550284, "turns": 19, "duration_seconds": 268, "subagents": 0, "tokens": { "input": 32, "output": 25464, "cache_read": 950222, "cache_creation": 81947 }, "modules_loaded": [ "motion-principles", "mobile-principles", "swiftui-motion" ], "modules_not_loaded": [], "interaction_thesis": "Tapping a slack-water row in Today makes that row grow into its tide detail, using SwiftUI's zoom navigation transition (`.matchedTransitionSource` on the row, `.navigationTransition(.zoom)` on the detail). The system sets the timing. The time you tapped becomes the detail's 56 pt headline. A back-swipe or a pull-down shrinks the detail into the same row, with the bell showing any alert you just set.", "allowed_patterns": "none", "unvalidated": true, "thesis_written_before_modules_loaded": true, "thesis_named_zoom_before_modules_loaded": true, "used_system_zoom_transition": true, "kept_navigation_stack_bar_back_button": true, "kept_edge_swipe_back": "yes, filmed, interactive", "any_drag_flickers": "no", "step_thesis_against_modules": { "printed": "Thesis against modules: no gap. The thesis already uses the approach the SwiftUI module recommends for a row that opens a screen, and it keeps the back-swipe.", "where": "final report only", "thesis_revised": false }, "swift_changed": { "files": 1, "insertions": 15, "deletions": 0 }, "files_changed": { "Etale/TodayView.swift": "@Namespace (line 7), matchedTransitionSource with the cell's background and 12 pt corners (36-42), navigationTransition(.zoom) on the destination (70)" }, "previews": [ "preview/today-to-detail.html", "preview/variants.html" ], "audit": { "summary": "8 checked, 1 problem found, 1 not checked, 3 not applicable, 2 handed over", "loaded_modules_against_code": "no departure", "problem": "12 pt corner radius typed in (TodayView.swift:81)", "reduced_motion": "not checked: no guard, left to the system" }, "build": { "result": "success", "first_try": true, "verbatim": "** BUILD SUCCEEDED **", "errors": [], "compiler_warnings": 0, "other_warnings": [ "warning: Metadata extraction skipped, no AppIntents.framework dependency found" ], "from": "a fresh copy of runs/20261113T220815Z/workspace-1, new derived data, iPhone 17 simulator on iOS 26.5" }, "human_edits": 0, "grader_score": { "score": 1.0, "note": "five of five, the same graders as run 1; they do not judge the motion" }, "defects": [ { "what": "on every return the zoom's source comes back as a white box much taller than the row, covering the 05:57 and 16:17 rows for about 130 ms; the time passes over the 05:57 row before it settles", "media": "media/run-4/defect-source-box.png" }, { "what": "on opening, for 1 to 2 frames, the 10:31 row floats above the 05:57 row" } ], "unverified": [ "Reduce Motion, dark appearance, large type: not filmed", "no real device", "no second check of the measurements" ], "media": [ { "file": "media/run-4/clip.webp", "kb": 722 }, { "file": "media/run-4/edge-swipe.webp", "kb": 436 }, { "file": "media/run-4/drag-down.webp", "kb": 413 }, { "file": "media/run-4/today.png" }, { "file": "media/run-4/detail.png" }, { "file": "media/run-4/defect-source-box.png" } ], "timing": "picture changes for 0.63 s opening, 0.93 s closing", "drag": "0 reversals over 75 samples at 60 fps", "note": "the run says it wrote preview/variants.html after the code, 'the wrong order'" }, { "run": 5, "runs_dir": "runs/20261113T220814Z", "media_dir": "media/run-5", "genjutsu": { "version": "4.2.0", "commit": "844f375", "commit_full": "844f37558c90215e4f7b93fdf96838f39c1e9967", "branch": "release/v4.2.0", "module_fixes": true, "step_thesis_against_modules": true }, "harness": { "tool": "claude plugin eval", "claude_code": "2.1.325", "headless": true, "note": "the same copy of bin/run.sh as run 3 with its paths changed, cost ceiling 6 USD; one run, started side by side with the two others" }, "started_at": "2026-11-13T22:08:14.947Z", "cost_usd": 1.3, "cost_usd_exact": 1.2995434, "turns": 18, "duration_seconds": 262, "subagents": 0, "tokens": { "input": 26, "output": 25493, "cache_read": 748857, "cache_creation": 79976 }, "modules_loaded": [ "motion-principles", "mobile-principles", "swiftui-motion" ], "modules_not_loaded": [], "interaction_thesis": "tapping a slack row in Today zooms that row open into its tide detail with SwiftUI's zoom navigation transition (`matchedTransitionSource` on the row, `.navigationTransition(.zoom(sourceID:in:))` on the detail). The slack you tapped becomes the screen instead of a page sliding over it, and the edge swipe or a drag down shrinks it back into the same row. The timing is the system's: the app sets no duration. With Reduce Motion on, the app keeps the same zoom call and leaves the reduced version to the system, which owns that transition. It never swaps in the default push.", "allowed_patterns": "none", "unvalidated": true, "thesis_written_before_modules_loaded": true, "thesis_named_zoom_before_modules_loaded": true, "used_system_zoom_transition": true, "kept_navigation_stack_bar_back_button": true, "kept_edge_swipe_back": "yes, filmed, interactive", "any_drag_flickers": "no", "step_thesis_against_modules": { "printed": "Revised after LOAD: Reduce Motion no longer falls back to the default push (a full-width slide) - motion-principles / swiftui-motion, reduced motion: large translations are neutralized", "where": "final report only; the gap line in the step's format was never printed", "thesis_revised": true, "before": "With Reduce Motion on, the app drops the zoom and the detail arrives with the system's default transition.", "preview_marked": "preview/thesis.html got the first line 'Shows the thesis before its revision after LOAD' and was not rebuilt", "side_effect": "the code has no Reduce Motion guard at all; what the system zoom does in that mode was not filmed" }, "swift_changed": { "files": 1, "insertions": 13, "deletions": 0 }, "files_changed": { "Etale/TodayView.swift": "@Namespace (line 7), matchedTransitionSource with its configuration (39-43), navigationTransition(.zoom) on the destination root (71)" }, "previews": [ "preview/thesis.html", "preview/variants.html" ], "audit": { "summary": "10 checked, 1 problem found, 1 not checked", "loaded_modules_against_code": "no departure", "problem": "cornerRadius: 12 (TodayView.swift:42)", "reduced_motion": "not checked, handed to a device" }, "build": { "result": "success", "first_try": true, "verbatim": "** BUILD SUCCEEDED **", "errors": [], "compiler_warnings": 0, "other_warnings": [ "warning: Metadata extraction skipped, no AppIntents.framework dependency found" ], "from": "a fresh copy of runs/20261113T220814Z/workspace-1, new derived data, iPhone 17 simulator on iOS 26.5" }, "human_edits": 0, "grader_score": { "score": 1.0, "note": "five of five, the same graders as run 1; they do not judge the motion" }, "defects": [ { "what": "the zoom's source shows as a white box on opening and on return: a large rounded white rectangle over the 10:31 and 16:17 rows about 0.3 to 0.4 s after Back, then a narrower one inside the still-grey cell until about 1 s after Back; run 2's defect, more marked", "media": "media/run-5/defect-source-box.png" }, { "what": "no Reduce Motion path at all after the run's own revision; not filmed" } ], "unverified": [ "Reduce Motion, dark appearance, large type: not filmed", "no real device", "no second check of the measurements" ], "media": [ { "file": "media/run-5/clip.webp", "kb": 378 }, { "file": "media/run-5/edge-swipe.webp", "kb": 440 }, { "file": "media/run-5/drag-down.webp", "kb": 397 }, { "file": "media/run-5/today.png" }, { "file": "media/run-5/detail.png" }, { "file": "media/run-5/defect-source-box.png" } ], "timing": "picture changes for 0.55 s opening, 0.97 s closing", "drag": "0 reversals over 73 frames at 60 fps", "duration_note": "262 s in the trace, 263 s printed by the harness", "media_note": "clips encoded afterwards from the measuring pass's 60 fps frames with takes/encode-clip.py (24 fps, q62, 402 px)" }, { "run": 6, "runs_dir": "runs/20261113T220820Z", "media_dir": "media/run-6", "genjutsu": { "version": "4.2.0", "commit": "844f375", "commit_full": "844f37558c90215e4f7b93fdf96838f39c1e9967", "branch": "release/v4.2.0", "module_fixes": true, "step_thesis_against_modules": true }, "harness": { "tool": "claude plugin eval", "claude_code": "2.1.325", "headless": true, "note": "the same copy of bin/run.sh as run 3 with its paths changed, cost ceiling 6 USD; one run, started side by side with the two others" }, "started_at": "2026-11-13T22:08:21.189Z", "cost_usd": 1.31, "cost_usd_exact": 1.3110324, "turns": 23, "duration_seconds": 269, "subagents": 0, "tokens": { "input": 30, "output": 25523, "cache_read": 847102, "cache_creation": 78879 }, "modules_loaded": [ "motion-principles", "mobile-principles", "swiftui-motion" ], "modules_not_loaded": [], "interaction_thesis": "Tapping a slack row in the Today list grows that row into its tide detail with the system zoom navigation transition (`.matchedTransitionSource` on the row, `.navigationTransition(.zoom)` on the detail, one shared `@Namespace` keyed by `slack.id`). The detail reads as the row opened up, not as a new page sliding in, and swiping down or back collapses it into the same row, interactively. As the detail arrives, the day's tide line draws left to right through the slack marker with `.smooth(duration: 0.45)`, no delay. With Reduce Motion, the system's own handling replaces the zoom and the line is shown already drawn.", "allowed_patterns": "none", "unvalidated": true, "thesis_written_before_modules_loaded": true, "thesis_named_zoom_before_modules_loaded": true, "used_system_zoom_transition": true, "kept_navigation_stack_bar_back_button": true, "kept_edge_swipe_back": "yes, filmed, interactive", "any_drag_flickers": "no", "step_thesis_against_modules": { "printed": "Revised after LOAD: line draw 0.6 s + 0.2 s delay → 0.45 s, no delay - motion-principles, never exceed 500ms on a UI interaction", "where": "final report only", "thesis_revised": true, "outside_the_step_text": "the step says a value the thesis chose is a decision left to the audit, not a gap", "missed": "the Reduce Motion question, which the audit then listed as a problem", "preview_marked": "preview/thesis.html got the first line 'Shows the thesis before its revision after LOAD.'" }, "swift_changed": { "files": 2, "insertions": 22, "deletions": 1 }, "files_changed": { "Etale/TodayView.swift": "+7: @Namespace (7), matchedTransitionSource (36), navigationTransition(.zoom) (65)", "Etale/TideDetailView.swift": "+15 -1: the tide line trimmed in with .smooth(duration: 0.45) on appear, drawn at rest under Reduce Motion" }, "previews": [ "preview/thesis.html", "preview/variants.html" ], "audit": { "summary": "9 checked, 1 problem found, 1 not checked, 2 not applicable", "loaded_modules_against_code": "1 problem: swiftui-motion, reduced motion: TodayView.swift:65 applies the zoom even with Reduce Motion on; true, left unfixed" }, "build": { "result": "success", "first_try": true, "verbatim": "** BUILD SUCCEEDED **", "errors": [], "compiler_warnings": 0, "other_warnings": [ "warning: Metadata extraction skipped, no AppIntents.framework dependency found" ], "from": "a fresh copy of runs/20261113T220820Z/workspace-1, new derived data, iPhone 17 simulator on iOS 26.5" }, "human_edits": 0, "grader_score": { "score": 1.0, "note": "five of five, the same graders as run 1; they do not judge the motion" }, "defects": [ { "what": "the line draw the thesis promises cannot be seen: the curve is complete from the first frame where it appears, about 30 ms after the zoom starts", "media": "media/run-6/open-mid.png" }, { "what": "the row's text floats over the shrinking detail for a few frames on return; the system zoom's own cross-fade", "media": "media/run-6/close-mid.png" }, { "what": "the zoom runs with Reduce Motion on (the audit's open problem); not filmed" } ], "unverified": [ "Reduce Motion, dark appearance, large type: not filmed", "no real device", "no second check of the measurements" ], "media": [ { "file": "media/run-6/clip.webp", "kb": 721 }, { "file": "media/run-6/edge-swipe.webp", "kb": 425 }, { "file": "media/run-6/drag-down.webp", "kb": 435 }, { "file": "media/run-6/today.png" }, { "file": "media/run-6/detail.png" }, { "file": "media/run-6/open-mid.png" }, { "file": "media/run-6/close-mid.png" } ], "timing": "picture changes for 0.53 s opening, 0.53 s closing", "drag": "0 reversals over 80 frames at 60 fps", "assumption": "I read 'not a push' as how it should look, not as a ban on navigation." } ], "counts": { "used_system_transition": { "before_module_fixes": { "runs": [ 1 ], "used": 0, "of": 1 }, "fixed_modules_without_step": { "runs": [ 2, 3 ], "used": 1, "of": 2 }, "fixed_modules_with_step": { "runs": [ 4, 5, 6 ], "used": 3, "of": 3 } }, "thesis_named_zoom_before_any_module_load": { "yes": [ 2, 4, 5, 6 ], "no": [ 1, 3 ] }, "step_revised_a_hand_built_thesis": { "times": 0, "of": 3, "note": "no run with the step wrote a hand-built thesis, so the path the step was written for is untested" }, "conclusion": "with the step 3 of 3 runs used the system transition, against 1 of 2 without it on the same fixed modules; in all three the thesis named the zoom before any module load, so the step had nothing of that kind to correct. If the rate without the step is 1 of 2, three in a row happens one time in eight by chance. The step's text is in cast's SKILL.md, read before the thesis is written, and may have steered the theses; nothing here shows it" }, "showcased_run": { "run": 2, "why": "one of six runs of this prompt; four used the system transition, two (runs 1 and 3) hand-built an overlay. No later run is clearly better: runs 4 and 5 show a larger white box than run 2's, run 6 has no white box but its one authored motion cannot be seen and its Reduce Motion problem is open, and run 2 is the only zoom run filmed under Reduce Motion, in dark appearance and at a large text size" }, "after_run_3": { "genjutsu_commits": [ "779f16c", "844f375" ], "branch": "release/v4.2.0", "on_top_of": "5105f53", "cause": "in cast the thesis and its preview are written before the modules load, so what a module teaches arrives after the decision; headless, the thesis is UNVALIDATED and the audit check can only list the departure once the code exists", "step": "skills/cast/SKILL.md and skills/paint/SKILL.md, 'Read the thesis against the modules, before any code': after the last load, walk the loaded modules' rules against the thesis; with someone there ask once, revise or keep; with nobody answering rewrite the thesis on the module's way, print it UNVALIDATED with a line 'Revised after LOAD: <what changed> - <module, rule>'" } }